Wow turns out both of my fans have been bad for god knows how long........ UGH!!
The VRSC fans used by HD are Spal "pull" type. For the early models (2002 & 2003) the fans used where Spal P/N VA31-A101-46 A. In 2004 HD changed these to a special dual fan unit = Spal P/N 2VA58-A101-46A. This dual unit is only available to HD.Mike_W,
Could you be more specific as to which fan is the right one? That web site sells a lot of different fans.