I lost an "I" on mine as well. The chrome/silver part fell off leaving the black rubber part still on the box. After being teased my bike had a black eye, I had to go to HD and buy the complete "Harley Davidson" lettering for one side. I think it was around sixty something dollars. I'm still sore from that purchase. The only good thing I can say is I have extra letters now, just as long as the "I" doesn't fall off again.